Scoring & roles

[Neil]

Scores below...

[Robin_C]

Proposal number: 301
Proposer: Robin
Votes for: 5
Outcome: passed
Score:
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 301 - 291 = 10
| | | | 10 * 5/5 = +10

Result = +10

Robin's score: 10

[michaelenstone]

Proposal number: 302
Proposer: Michael
Votes for: 5/6
Outcome: failed
Score:
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 302 - 291 = 11
| | | | 11 * 5/6 = +9
| | Rule 206:
| | | | -10
| | Result:
| | | | -1

[Neil]

Proposal number: 304 & 305
Proposer: Neil
Votes for: 6/6
Outcome: Passed
Score:
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 304 - 291 = 13
| | | | 13 * 6/6 = 13
| | | | 305 - 291 = 14
| | | | 14 * 6/6 = 14
| | Result:
| | | | +27

[ariich]

Proposal number: 306
Proposer: Rich
Votes for: 6/6
Outcome: Passed
Score:
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 306 - 291 = 15
| | | | 15 * 6/6 = 15
| | Result:
| | | | +15

Plus I chose to be a Craftsman during the proposal, so another +3.

[oafcmetty]

Proposal number: 307
Proposer: Alex
Outcome: Rejected

Voting
Alex: For
Neil: Against
Dom: No Vote (for) x 3 (underdog 6th)
Michael: Against x 2 (underdog 5th)
Robin: Against
Rich: Against

Score
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 307 - 291 = 16
| | | | 16 * 4/9 = +7
| | Rule 206:
| | | | -10
| | Result:
| | | | -3

[Neil]

Proposal number: 308
Proposer: Dom
Outcome: Rejected

Voting
Alex: Against
Neil: Against
Dom: For x 3 (underdog 6th)
Michael: Against x 2 (underdog 5th)
Robin: For
Rich: Against

Score
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 308 - 291 = 17
| | | | 17 * 4/9 = +8
| | Rule 206:
| | | | -10
| | Result:
| | | | -2

 Scores & roles after 308

Cooper	Craftsman	19
Enstone	Craftsman	8
Holton	Craftsman	36
Jones	Craftsman	24
Metcalfe	Craftsman	6
Probyn	Policeman	-2

[Robin_C]

Proposal number: 309
Proposer: RC
Outcome: Passed

Voting
All: for

Score
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 309 - 291 = 18
| | | | 18 * 100% = +18
| | Result:
| | | | +18 for RC
+10 for the Bank

I am a Thief so:
Neil: (insured against loss) 0
Mike: (insured against loss) 0
Alex: +1.5 (takes half, minus 1 I stole from him)
Dom: -1
Rich: (insured against loss) 0
Robin: +2.5 (half of one point from every player)
Bank: -3 from insurance

Craftsmen pay insurance:
Enstone: -1
Holton: -1
Rich: -1

Policeman gets paid:
Alex: 0.7

Thus:

Scores & roles after 309
Cooper     Thief 39.5
Enstone    Craftsman 8
Holton      Craftsman 36
Jones       Craftsman 23
Metcalfe   Policeman 10.2
Probyn     (no role) -3
Bank          7

 ######################################################################
Correction - NH:
Thieves only steal from people with positive points.
Robin and Alex incorrectly attributed half a point each
Also, policemen's pay is rounded up before distribution:
Correct values:
Dom = +-0
Robin = +2
Alex = +1 +1 (0.7 rounded up)

Resulting:
Probyn (no role) -2
Cooper Thief 39
Metcalfe Policeman 10

 Scores & roles after 308

Cooper	Craftsman	19
Enstone	Craftsman	8
Holton	Craftsman	36
Jones	Craftsman	24
Metcalfe	Craftsman	6
Probyn	Policeman	-2

Scores & roles after 309

Cooper	Thief	39
Enstone	Craftsman	10
Holton	Craftsman	38
Jones	Craftsman	26
Metcalfe	Policeman	8
Probyn	No Role	-2
Bank	N/A	7

[michaelenstone]

Voting
Alex: Against x 2 (underdog 5th)
Neil: For
Dom: No Vote (for) x 3 (underdog 6th)
Michael: For
Robin: Against
Rich: For

Score
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 310 - 291 = 19
| | | | 19 * 6/9 = +12.7
| | Rule 206:
| | | | -10
| | Craftsman:
| | | | +3
| | Insurance:
| | | | -1
| | Result:
| | | | +4.7

Bank: +11 points

Policemen: 1.8 points

[Neil]

Proposal number: 310
Proposer: Enstone
Outcome: Rejected

Voting
Alex: Against x 2 (underdog 5th)
Neil: For
Dom: No Vote (for) x 3 (underdog 6th)
Michael: For
Robin: Against
Rich: For

Proposal score
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 310 - 291 = 19
| | | | 19 * 6/9 = +13
| | Rule 206:
| | | | -10
| | Result:
| | | | +3

Role scoring
Bank:+10 (bank) -3 (insured theft) = +7
Craftsmen: +3 (craft) -1 (insurance) = +2
Thieves: +4 (theft) / 2
Policemen: +4/2 (theives' takings) + 2 (10% bank = 1.4 rounded up) -1 (theft)
Artists: Not today, Pablo
No-roles: -1 (theft)

Scores & roles after 309

Cooper	Thief	39
Enstone	Craftsman	10
Holton	Craftsman	38
Jones	Craftsman	26
Metcalfe	Policeman	8
Probyn	No Role	-2
Bank	N/A	7

Scores & roles after 310

Cooper	Thief	41
Enstone	Craftsman	15
Holton	Craftsman	40
Jones	Craftsman	28
Metcalfe	Policeman	11
Probyn	No Role	-2
Bank	N/A	14

[Neil]

Proposal number: 311/312
Proposer: Neil
Outcome: Rejected

Voting
Alex: Against x 2 (underdog 5th)
Neil: No vote
Dom: For x 3 (underdog 6th)
Michael: For
Robin: No vote
Rich: For

Proposal score
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 311 - 291 = 20
| | | | 20 * 5/7 = +14
| | | | 312 - 291 = 21
| | | | 21 * 5/7 = +15
| | Rule 206:
| | | | -10
| | | | -10
| | Result:
| | | | +9

Role scoring
Bank:+10 (bank) -2 (insured theft) = +8
Craftsmen: +3 (craft) -1 (insurance) = +2
Thieves: +4 (theft) / 2
Policemen: +4/2 (theives' takings) /2 policemen = +1
+ 3 (10% bank = 2.2 rounded up) / 2 policemen = +1.5
-1 (theft)
Artists: Not today, Pablo
No-roles: -1 (theft)

Scores & roles after 310

Cooper	Thief	41
Enstone	Craftsman	15
Holton	Craftsman	40
Jones	Craftsman	28
Metcalfe	Policeman	11
Probyn	No Role	-2
Bank	N/A	14

Scores & roles after 312

Cooper	Thief	43
Enstone	Craftsman	17
Holton	Policeman	50.5
Jones	Craftsman	30
Metcalfe	Policeman	12.5
Probyn	No Role	-2
Bank	N/A	22

[Robin_C]

Proposal number: 313
Proposer: Rich
Outcome: Rejected

Voting
All: against

Proposal score
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 313 - 291 = 22
| | | | 22 * 0  = 0
| | Rule 206:
| | | | -10
| | Result:
| | | | -10

Rich is insured against loss though (moral hazard here, as it removes his need to propose)

Role scoring
Bank:+10 (bank) -2 (insured theft) = +8
Craftsmen: +3 (craft) -1 (insurance) = +2
Thieves: +4 (theft) / 2 = +2
Policemen: +4/2 (theives' takings) /2 policemen = +1
+ 3 (10% bank = 3 rounded up) / 2 policemen = +1.5
-1 (theft)
Artists: Not today, Pablo
No-roles: -1 (theft)

Scores & roles after 312
Cooper Thief 43
Enstone Craftsman 17
Holton Policeman 50.5
Jones        Craftsman 30
Metcalfe Policeman 12.5
Probyn No Role -2
Bank        N/A 22

Scores & roles after 312
Cooper Thief 45
Enstone Craftsman 19
Holton Policeman 52
Jones   Craftsman 32
Metcalfe Policeman 14
Probyn No Role -2
Bank N/A 30

[oafcmetty]

Someone will have to tell me what the running totals are - Neil's post has a version after 312, and Robin's has two other versions for after 312 (typo?).

In terms of points from my turn, I think the following applies:

Proposal number: 314
Proposer: Alex
Outcome: Accepted

Voting
All: For

Proposal score
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 314 - 291 = 23
| | | | 23 * 100% = +23
| | Result:
| | | | +23 for AM

Need to work out the other stuff though (unless someone wants to do it for me!)

[oafcmetty]

Proposal number: 314
Proposer: Alex
Outcome: Accepted

Voting
All: For

Proposal score
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 314 - 291 = 23
| | | | 23 * 100% = +23
| | Result:
| | | | +23 for AM

Role scoring
Bank:+10 (bank) -2 (insured theft) = +8
Craftsmen: +3 (craft) -1 (insurance) = +2
Thieves: +4 (theft) / 2 = +2
Policemen: +4/2 (thieves' takings) /2 policemen = +1
+ 4 (10% bank) / 2 policemen = +2
-1 (theft)
Artists: Not today, Pablo
No-roles: -1 (theft)

Scores & roles after 313
Cooper Thief 45
Enstone Craftsman 19
Holton Policeman 52
Jones Craftsman 32
Metcalfe Policeman 14
Probyn No Role -2
Bank N/A 30

Scores & roles after 314
Cooper Thief 47
Enstone Craftsman 21
Holton Policeman 54
Jones Craftsman 34
Metcalfe Policeman 39
Probyn No Role -2
Bank N/A 38

Think that's right?

[oafcmetty]

Proposal number: 318
Proposer: Alex
Outcome: Accepted

Voting
All but Neil: For
Neil: Against

Proposal score
| | Rule 202:
| | | | 318 - 291 = 27
| | | | 27 * 8/9 = +24
| | Result:
| | | | +24 for AM
| | Rule 204:
| | | | +10 for Neil

Role scoring
Bank:+10 (bank) -2 (insured theft) = +8
Craftsmen: +3 (craft) -1 (insurance) = +2
Thieves: +4 (theft) / 2 = +2
Policemen: +4/2 (thieves' takings) /2 policemen = +1
+ 5 (10% bank) / 2 policemen = +2.5
-1 (theft)
Artists: Not today, Pablo
No-roles: -1 (theft)

Scores & roles after 314
Cooper Thief 47
Enstone Craftsman 21
Holton Policeman 54
Jones Craftsman 34
Metcalfe Policeman 39
Probyn No Role -2
Bank N/A 38

Scores & roles after 318
Cooper Thief 49
Enstone Craftsman 23
Holton Policeman 66.5
Jones Craftsman 36
Metcalfe Policeman 65.5
Probyn No Role -2
Bank N/A 46

[Sponsored content]